Wednesday, February 6, 2008

The Week in Fourth Grade



As I go through Isa's fourth grade textbooks, I spot things that bother me. I understand the need for simplification, but at the expense of fact? Or am I being too picky?
Here's a lab to do at home from the science book:

Cut up an apple and measure and record the mass of the fresh apple slices.

I don't know about you, but I have nothing to measure mass in my kitchen.

Here's one from the art book:

Portraits of Gabriele Munter show the artist as a sweet, dainty woman. In fact, this artist was an important figure in the world of art. She played a large role in the rise of an art movement.


Wow, I guess we're going up against that old-fashioned portrait portrayal, aren't we? Because now they are giving us facts.

Finally, this little tidbit from once more, the science book.

An estuary is a place where fresh water and salt water meet, such as a river meeting an ocean. The amount of salt in the water changes many times a day, so only a few types of organisms can live in an estuary.


Who wrote this? Exxon? A 'lifestyle community' developer that needs to get rid of these pesky estuaries so he can put in a golf course? The No Child Left Behind Committee?

UPDATE: The next section has a cloud seeding section, and says that silver iodide is OK. I feel ill.

Labels: , , ,

3 Comments:

Blogger Ken L. said...

On the one hand - estuaries, a place where only a few things can live? Estuaries are extremely productive habitats essential to millions of migrating birds (largely for the prey that they find living there!), many species of fish (often serving as piscine nurseries), etc.
On the other hand - learning anything in fourth grade about Gabriele Munter - Impressive!!

February 6, 2008 8:14 PM  
Blogger Jack Silbert said...

In 4th grade, I was much more interested in Herman Munster than Gabriele Munter.

February 8, 2008 9:06 AM  
Blogger Jack Silbert said...

So I just got back in my apartment, flipped on the radio, and the first lyrics I hear mention Gabriele Munter! Who I must admit I'd never heard of before this blog post. So I stay tuned to find out what the song is. Well, it was a live performance of a new song by the great Syd Straw, off her not-yet-out first album in 12 years. Legendary free-form DJ Vin Scelsa hadn't heard of Munter either, so Syd talked about her for a few moments. I feel smart.

February 9, 2008 6:23 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home