Friday, January 4, 2008

Used books

Courts across the land are presently working out the legal issues regarding downloading, duplicating and sharing of digital media.

But when it comes to books, these issues were worked out long ago. When you buy a book, you are free to give it away, sell it to any buyer for any agreed-upon price, throw it in a fire, donate it to charity, or store it on a shelf. Or, if you'd rather not buy the book, you can borrow it from a library at no charge. All perfectly legal!

The Text and Academic Authoring Association is working hard to call these practices into question. The reason I know this is that I recently became a member, by virtue of attending a writing workshop at my university a few months ago. I've gotten two of their newsletters so far. In the latest, there was an article trying to quantify just how much money was being lost because of the existence of used bookstores. Another featured tips on how to write textbooks that will obsolesce rapidly, helping to suppress the secondary market (example: include as many URLs as possible, since these won't work after a few years). There are form letters you can mail to your senators, asking for support of legislation restricting the ability to buy and sell used books, and ideas for how to reform your campus bookstore. As someone who has bought used books almost exclusively for my entire life, this is just mind-boggling. I don't see them wielding much influence, though. And what kind of name is "Text and Academic Authoring Association", anyway? The word "text" in that phrase makes no sense.

Labels: ,

4 Comments:

Blogger John Levenstein said...

very interesting, i'd never heard of this (these people are getting nowhere)

January 5, 2008 11:27 AM  
Blogger Bernie said...

I think they have succeeded in ripping off millions of college students! In my case, anyway, for the past few years it has been impossible to purchase a (new) book for a course, and then sell it at the end of the term. The book store manager apologizes, and says they are using a new edition, or sometimes cite the pesky URLs or the disks in the back (even if unused) as copyright reasons for why the books cannot be sold again. Also, every book i buy these days has a CD in the back (again, never used by the professor).
These books are very expensive, $180 was my last one, and very thin, clocking in at 200 pages if that.
One noble professor I had saw the light and told his students they did not need to buy the textbook for the class; that if they followed his online syllabus, they would do just fine. The racket disgusted him, he said. He told me it's the same book but they will change a page number or two and force everyone to buy new books and I have to go in and re-do all my sheets, which is not that big a deal but the fleecing of the students bothers me so much I'm going to not require them to purchase the book.
I wonder how long he gets away with that before he gets into "trouble".
Amazon, too, is helpful for students who have all but abandoned the idea of finding a used book in a college bookstore, but it carries a bit of risk, getting a different edition. But so far, I have seen professors have been understanding of students' plights.

January 5, 2008 12:31 PM  
Blogger John Levenstein said...

i think we're saying the same thing.

January 5, 2008 1:14 PM  
Blogger Robert said...

You said it with less passion (one of my pet peeves in sitcom scenes).

January 6, 2008 4:25 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home