NPR Humor

On a recent road trip, NPR was humming along in the background, barely audible. There was laughter, so John turned up the volume. It was a woman telling a Thanksgiving story, about being filled with stress about her parents coming to New York City to see her. She spoke in what I can only call that "classic NPR tone"-- dry and over-enunciating. You. Can. Hear. Her. Now. She said, "My father sat in a chair all day," and paused for full dramatic effect, "and kept telling jokes. That weren't funny."
The unseen audience roared with laughter. The three of us looked quizzically at one another. John turned the volume up a little more and the woman continued talking about her mother. She said, "I knew my mother would say something about the cornbread. To her, there is only one kind of cornbread, and it wasn't what I had. My mother said, 'That isn't cornbread, that's something you put in your hair.'"
Again, the audience went wild with maniacal laughter.
Finally Isa said, "I just don't see why they are laughing so hard."
"Me neither," I said.
Just then we heard her talking about taking her parents to Ellis Island. It was cold, it was rainy, her piece went on and on for minutes (another NPR trait: lots of needless descriptive turns of phrase, I would think for traffic but she was performing live) and then she said, with more enunciation than the radio speaker could possibly bear: "The problem with going to Ellis Island-"
and she paused, for great dramatic effect here (and I could picture her looking up at her audience with a gleam in her eye as she delivered her punchline) IS THAT YOU ARE GOING TO ELLIS ISLAND.
John turned off the radio.
That's right, the problem with Ellis Island is that you are going to Ellis Island.
Labels: Ellis Island, huddled masses, Isa, kids say the darndest things, travels, unsolicited criticism, yearning

27 Comments:
a theme seems to be emerging of isa having a low tolerance for unearned laughter.
and Bernie's quixotic engagements with mediocrity.
Incidentally, if you listen to NPR on AM (not an option for many of you, I know, but we have it in Albany) the programming sound like it was recorded long ago.
That was a Sarah Vowell piece, right? On the one hand, the audience is so over-the-top about her that they'll laugh at whatever she says. On the other hand, unfortunately the over-the-top reaction makes her come off a lot worse than she really is. Like if she'd delivered the stupid Ellis Island line as part of a taped show, with no audience, you might not have even noticed it, or if you did, you wouldn't have cared that much. But when the audience goes that crazy for a bad line, she winds up playing into it and both the laughter and her vamping make her sound bad.
Some of her stories are great. Her Sinatra piece on This American Life (episode 54, if you're curious) is terrific.
John, Bernie - you're older and set in your ways so there may be no convincing you. But please don't turn Isa against Sarah Vowell. That would be so so unfair.
Oh, FYI - This American Life isn't on NPR. It's on Public Radio International.
All I'm asking is for you to play fair.
do i have to play fair with ira glass?
because i don't like the way he smacks his lips.
I don't know if it was Sarah Vowell or not. If it was, I've made it this far without her, I can certainly continue this way.
And if I've slandered NPR unfairly, I apologize.
very classy
For the record, I'm a big fan of Sarah Vowell. I even went to see her at the Troy Savings Bank Music Hall.
I don't know who wrote the monologue we listened to in the car but it was not funny, touching or music hally in any way.
Bernie: the show you described had sounded very much like This American Life, so I'd found this description of a TAL segment for the week you were on your road trip:
Regular TAL contributor Sarah Vowell takes over the family Thanksgiving dinner by bringing everyone to New York. What results is a series of milestones and family firsts. Everyone in the family is the kind of person who prefers to be alone, so the very thing that binds them together as a family actually makes it hard for them to spend time together.
Does this sound like what you'd heard?
Frank: are you a TAL fan in general?
John: In general, TAL is much better when it's prerecorded than when it's live. And you don't need to be fair to Ira Glass. All I'm asking from you - frankly, all I've ever asked from you - is to just please have some common decency.
Robert:
"Regular TAL contributor Sarah Vowell takes over the family Thanksgiving dinner by bringing everyone to New York. What results is a series of milestones and family firsts. Everyone in the family is the kind of person who prefers to be alone, so the very thing that binds them together as a family actually makes it hard for them to spend time together."
This sounds awful.
Wow.
Bernie, suppose you write a blog entry and you include a tag yearning. Hardly anyone notices. But now you're doing it in front of a live audience who adores you, and as you type the inappropriate tag yearning everyone gasps and applauds like it's the greatest thing in the world. Then someone else comes along and sees your tag and hears everyone gasp and applaud like it's so great and so they write an entry on their own blog ripping you to shreds, when if the audience wasn't there to adore you they wouldn't even have noticed the inappropriate tag in the first place. And then they write a summary of your blog entry in their blog and says your blog entry was ridiculous. Is that fair? (Here's a hint: No, it's not.)
these weren't throw aways, these were "laugh lines," her versions of jokes. she was laying into them and waiting for a reaction. it is easy to get laughs in that environment. that's why the onus is on the performer to be funny--they're going to get the laughs, so they may as well earn them.
Also, I was criticizing the piece, not the (unknown) person. There is a huge difference.
it might be smaller than you think.
I'm mostly trying to be funny but now I think it came off too seriously. I'll start using smiley's a lot more!!! :)
This has shattered the record for comments received on a single posting.
I'll keep that in mind when I turn on the radio in the car again.
And yes, I am definitely a fan of This American Life. I still have never seen the TV version.
i hear it's good, but i've never seen it either (twenty-one!)
Frank, John told me awhile ago that he can't take This American Life because Ira Glass smacks his lips. I'd never noticed before - but now when Ira Glass talks, that's all I can hear.
it's a terrible thing you just did to frank.
Robert, when I was fourteen, someone told me Gatorade (which I loved dearly) was too salty. I've never had it since.
Gatorade is not salty enough.
Lip-smacking should be pretty easy to EQ out if necessary. But the strength of the show is not so much Ira Glass as who he surrounds himself with.
ira glass may not be the one who makes the show good, but he can sure spoil it for you.
Post a Comment
<< Home